jump to navigation

BPI Elections - but is it a wasted vote? July 1, 2008

Posted by Paul Birch in : BPI , add a comment

Lets be honest about the BPI – it represents the majors pretty well, as for the independents, that’s another matter. BPI has already shown they are ready to change the constitution, even twice in one month, just to hold on to the majors.

The test is how committed they are to the Indies that’s at issue.

If you asked them if they would put the interests of any 100 members above the interests of the smallest of the majors, and they had to answer you truthfully, they would have to say “No we can’t do that”.

How about 200 members then? – Still no.

The entire membership? Still no.

Take the Chart for instance. As irrelevant as it is, the information that flows from it is important data. To market effectively Indies need this information, but the minimum charge to get it in any useful format is £3500.00. Recently as a result of pressure, the OCC introduced a lower subscription rate, but took away most of the useful tools – meaning Indies that can afford less are second class data citizens under the new deal. And in the 21st Century, information is power, we all know that. Can it be the BPI just don’t want the Indies to catch-up?

Companies have to make a choice. You either take the “One nation” view, goes like this; “We are all record companies together, doesn’t matter if we are majors or Indies, we all have the same problems. Yes there are areas we disagree – but come on we can work it out. We are all basically all on the same side”

Then there is the other view; “things used to be like that, but now the majors only represent themselves. They don’t trust us anymore, maybe for good reason, but we have to move-on and develop an Independent agenda for what we want for our side in any negotiations, and we have to join that up with AIM and IMPALA. When we have that one-view, we can then negotiate with the majors”

Sorry, I am sure there are at least three hundred views in-between, but you have to lean towards one or the other.

I am going to be honest. If you are for the first statement, don’t vote for me, I ain’t delivering that. Mike Batt’s your man for that, not me. You want to know where you stand with me, I am at statement two. In fact I used to be a statement one man. After I negotiated the creation of the Vice-chairman position to level the playing field for the Indies, the BPI intervened to allow the majors a vote on the Independent they wanted to see as Vice Chairman. The Indies were split on their vote, but the majors as usual voted unanimously. No surprise then they voted for the man they most wanted to negotiate with; Batt.

In this life, we have to be careful what we wish for….we just might get it!

How does that Meat Loaf song go?

BPI to hold second EGM in reversal of fortunes over EMI & SONY BMG February 12, 2008

Posted by Paul Birch in : BPI, EMI, Paul Birch, SONY BMG, Terra Firma , add a comment

BPI to amend amendment aimed at retaining EMI, now aimed at retaining Sony BMG

Well, you couldn’t make it up. BPI who on the 12th February held an EGM to change its constitution aimed at retaining EMI as members, couldn’t convince more than 15% of its members to write in to change the fourth amendment to its Memo and Arts in as many years. Having written out to member asking for their support, BPI now find themselves in the embarrassing position of writing out to members again some time soon, this time asking them to reverse the decision.

Management gone mad?

BPI went to great pains to convince members to alter the constitution following EMI’s notice to quit BPI sister organisation IFPI. BPI’s vice chairman even wrote out asking for support, but only 1 in 6 companies responded. The rule which until the 12th Feb. required members of BPI to also be members of IFPI was altered to uncouple from IFPI, in the hope that the lifeboats wouldn’t be dragged under with the ship.

EMI are on a collision path with its peers over ditching support for IFPI, which lobbies on piracy and political issues. EMI have handed in a notice to quit the IFPI International trade group. Under the circumstances this also means that BPI will have to come to terms with the fact that EMI will also have to leave the BPI National Group.

Realising all this put EMI on a path where defacto they had to resign from BPI, BPI bosses ordered their lawyers to draft changes to the constitution in order that they could hang on to EMI when the inevitable becomes a reality at the end of February.

However, our Industry friends, reliable sources and Industry insiders tell us totally on the QT, hush hush and on the low, that the nice people at SONY BMG were more than a little irritated over the shenanigans. Who can blame them? I have a SONY TV so I am on their side.

A lot of members thought the whole shooting-match farcical. That BPI would hold an EGM to change the rules to hang on to just one member! Now, within a month they are in the embarrassing position of having to hold another EGM on March 12th to reverse the earlier decision, in order to hold on to an even more important member; SONY BMG.

One insider said; “it’s like Alien versus Predator in here”. There’s a lot of gnashing of teeth, saliva and tongue biting going on, and that’s just from the lawyers!

EMI about to join AIM and declare Independence? February 5, 2008

Posted by Paul Birch in : AIM, BPI, EMI, IMPALA, Paul Birch , add a comment

As the BPI changes its constitution to try to hang on to EMI, are EMI intending to join AIM / IMPALA / WIN and abandon IFPI and BPI all together?

BPI sceptic Roger Ames alleged arch evil over lord and chief scheme plotter behind Guy Hands is plotting in his shed

The EMI digital away-day, two years ago at Wright Lane, should have been the writing on the wall. Ted Cohen ran new media and was the main speaker at an event meant to open up New media to music minors and give them a major perspective on how EMI were taking on the difficult issues. EMI flew people in from Asia and all over the world it was a very impressive event laid on just for the independents. But not just any independents, as EMI’s fellow BPI and IFPI members were not invited. At least one BPI council member resigned in outrage. But these were the days when Alain Levy was in charge and he made sure no IFPI or BPI members were present. Madness. Why invite half the Indies and bar the other half, especially the ones that are meant to be part of your own trade association?

EMI have been cosying up to AIM for the longest time. We are about to see what it all means. Industry insiders reckon Guy Hands will be planning to sit down some time soon with Martin Mills to work this all out. It would look like a major PR advantage that would take the music world by storm and might even do something for share prices for a change.

Putting £1 or 2M into AIM/IMPALA/ WIN would buy them a lot more influence, that kind of money doesn’t go very far with IFPI, after all BPI costs alone amount to nearly £8M a year to run the place. Then there is the opportunity to be closer to the Indie community. For instance they could meet new friends, then buy them!

EMI, the end is nigh! January 17, 2008

Posted by Paul Birch in : BPI, EMI, IFPI, New Music, Paul Birch , add a comment

How many hands do you need to run Britain’s longest running Record Company? Obviously only one: Guy Hands. Soon he might be the only one left as he dis-members arguably the worlds finest Recording company. Since Hands has fired 2000 of EMI’s 5000 employees centering operations in London, everyone is waiting to see what he does next (hide the matches).

He has already explained to the press he doesn’t want EMI to be about signing new music any more. And we all thought he was some savvy suit from the city who was going to streamline (cut and paste) operations and raise share values. If EMI doesn’t stand for new music any more, then what exactly does it stand for? And can EMI share prices sustain such profoundly moronic behavior.

You couldn’t make it up (Hide the Gin), Guy Hands is on the loose, cheque book in one hand and a hatchet in the other. Pity all the cheques have a face value of less than $1.00

If you dropped him in the jungle with a machete and a satellite phone, he wouldn’t last 5 minutes before he succumbed to the blade. With only his own head left, he simply couldn’t resist the temptation! Even though he was only a quarter of a mile from the closest City Bank.

With one in three EMI employees now officially INDEPENDENT, Guy hands proves the rule, you can parachute in experts from other industries and immediately they cease to be experts in our industry. Roll on the merger with the brothers at Warner. Meanwhile EMI have given IFPI (and defacto BPI) notice to quit, as Guy Hands seeks to save his subscription to the cost of running the industry. Is this the end of the IFPI, the BPI and the other trade associations if not the end of EMI? Watch this space.